Located on a small Indian Reservation in the backcountry of northern San Diego county, the existing historical chapel, a satellite associated with Mission San Luis Rey, was the symbolic heart of the Rincon community until it was destroyed by the Poomacho wildfire in October of 2007. This was a painful blow to the community that had celebrated many of their family’s most important events inside this beloved chapel; weddings, funerals, and baptisms. Only the original mission bell and adobe tower survived, which naturally became the anchor element in the redesign.
The needs of the current community had changed quite a bit in the past 100 years. The fire presented a blank slate opportunity to update and enlarge the facility, primarily by doubling the seating capacity and adding a stand alone multipurpose fellowship hall, which created a third space, a landscaped courtyard in between the two structures.
Emulating or recreating the past literally was not a project goal. The new design was conceived to reverently knit together past and comfortable traditions, while acknowledging and offering something relevant to current and future generations. Drawing from a limitless well of Native American and Catholic symbols/metaphors, design elements in plan, section, and elevation all reference and infuse layers of meaning into the chapel, some obvious, other subtle.
One of the first questions the design team asked the client was if they wanted to a “green” or sustainable project. George Arviso, head of the Church Committee, got a wry smile on his face, amused by the naiveté of my inquiry, responding “we have been living on this land in a sustainable way for thousands of years.” Employing a combination of hi-tech products as well as many lo-tech passive features, the project intentionally lives lighter on the land designed to consume significantly less energy (-29%), produces approximately 40% of its own electrical needs and a thoughtful landscape design utilizes significantly less water (-62%) than comparably sized structures.
The client specifically requested a highly fire resistant structure. This led to one of the most unique features of the Chapel, the 2 foot thick rammed earth walls that flank the sanctuary. A 180 tons of earth for these walls was harvested directly on site, symbolically important because sacred soil from the reservation was literally molded to form these beautifully textured and organic walls. The rammed earth walls are also reminiscent of the adobe construction found all over the reservation; assuming both modern and traditional sensibilities at the same time. The baptismal font fashioned from a 3.5 ton site-found boulder, the altar fabricated with solid 6” thick slabs of hand hewn wood from a +100 year old Coastal Live Oak, are just some of the earthy materials that were employed to physically connect this congregation to the beauty of their natural surroundings and the sacred connection to their land.
Submitted by inthenameofthefather on Wed, 09/14/2011 - 02:39.
I called the architect 2 weeks ago for directions and Mass times, despite my odd request he was gracious and gave me both, plus ansered a few extra questions. He obviously is very proud of this project, how cool!
You are correct; St. Bartholomew's Chapel won an Orchid in 2010 for Interior Design and so it is not eligible for an Orchid in the Interior Design category. However, this year it was nominated in the Architecture category and is therefore eligible in this different category.
Submitted by Arch lover on Fri, 09/02/2011 - 16:40.
Those crazy tall windows on either side of the altar are really wonderful as they totally open up the space. I would think that windows in front, especially ones with a view would be a distraction during service, but these being so narrow seem to do just the trick. bellisima!
Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 08/30/2011 - 08:07.
This chapel is quite hip and modern, not expected in the rural back country. I remember seeing in and Irving Gill book that he designed a church on and Indian reservation.
Submitted by Glenn Younger on Sat, 09/10/2011 - 01:09.
Irving Gill DID design a church on an Indian Reservation and it is still being used. It is on the Barona reservation, Blessed Kateri Tekakwitha Parish.
1932 the Barona Band of Mission Indians decided that having their own place of worship was one of their first priorities. With the help of architect Irving J. Gill, tribal elders funded and built the church, which was dedicated to the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary on August 15th 1934.
View pictures at:
http://www.bktparish.com/Barona.htmlhttp://www.bktparish.com/Barona_files/shapeimage_4.png
Submitted by Anonymous on Tue, 08/30/2011 - 08:01.
New to the area, I didn't even know there were Indian reservations in San Diego. Looks like my husband and I are going to have to go for a drive and visit this place in person. The glass blocks are really neat.
Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 08/29/2011 - 03:38.
California is always linked to earthquakes, but wildfires have been increasingly destructive. I haven't seen this building in person, but the photos tell a really neat story, a phoenix rising from the ashes. Location looks beautiful and the chapel just snuggles right in. I like it.
Submitted by Anonymous on Mon, 08/29/2011 - 03:28.
Why don't we see more rammed earth buildings they are so cool, totally recyclable, and very low maintenance. Kudos to those who built this amazing chapel.
Submitted by Anonymous on Thu, 08/25/2011 - 18:40.
The architect's artful integration of the original mission bell and adobe tower, which had survived the fire, and his careful consideration of the history of the tribe and it's cultural traditions gives this modern design an organic and grounded feeling. I particularly like the decision to incorporate the rammed earth walls made from the sacred soil of the Reservation. The architect clearly worked hard with the tribal elders to create a compelling design for the new Chapel that is both open, yet protected; graceful, yet humble and looks to the future with a sense of hope and mindfulness.
I called the architect 2
Didn't this project win an
You are correct; St.
Those crazy tall windows on
Solid
Good design + sustainable =
This is really fun church,
Where are the people?
interesting......
The floating roof is awesome
These photographs don't do the Chapel justice
Unexpectedly modern
Irving Gill DID design a
Where is this?
Appropriate.
Very cool Rammed Earth project
This is such a beautiful and thoughtful design.